I was a preteen girl back when one of the best things about the music industry was the excitement of a new music video release. I'd rush home from school to make sure I didn't miss TRL, a music video Top 10 program on MTV, and cheered on my favorite bands for the number one spot. I never realized how many degrading images of women I was absorbing in a mere hour's time.
Seeing video after video I recognized in the Dreamworlds 3 documentary really opened my eyes to what I'd either missed or forgotten. Suddenly I remembered how disappointed I was when Jewel was suddenly shaking her hips in a skimpy outfit instead of playing guitar just because she was now endorsed by a brand of razor. I thought--
"Oh yeah! When I was young, you either had to be Jennifer Love Hewitt lusted after by all of LFO, or... Jennifer Love Hewitt saved by Enrique Iglesias in the desert!"
miss_rogue @ flickr |
I remembered this monstrosity. Not only did the video for "Dontcha" fall right into the pattern of objectifying women, it wanted the men to pay attention. It asked them to fantasize and to use the women in the video as objects because they were better than the reality of any girlfriend.
Last night I set out on a quest to find a video that defied the odds, because more disheartening to me than the treatment of women in men's entertainment was the seeming compliance of female performers. It was in this search that I stumbled upon a pattern. Women who played instruments - guitar and piano most common - were the ones most often allowed to tell a story from their own point of view.
Maybe it was already believed that women would be the target audiences for this genre of music, or maybe the fact that a story was built into the song itself spared them from falling into the 'lack of creativity' that other videos show. Either way, it was something to get hopeful about, something that showed that there is a light at the end of a loooooong tunnel of booty shaking babes.
Here was one exception I thoroughly enjoyed. A woman telling a story about her own exception, and keeping her clothes on in the process.